Friday, August 1, 2008

Jesus the Victim of Capital Punishment

Jesus: Victim of Capital Punishment


A study on this topic must take in mind the differing social, political and legal contexts existing in the world today. Those who engage in discussion of this topic will also bring their own faith experience to a dialogue about the criminal legal system and especially the unfortunate innocent victims of unfair criminal justice administration existing in some countries today.

Capital punishment is a particularly difficult and controversial ethical issue that has been long and hotly debated issue for centuries. The issue has evoked strong and widely differing opinions, all of which contain elements of the truth. Some believe that it is fair and just to administer the death penalty when criminals take a life or the lives of others while others think that it represents cruel and unusual, inhuman and abnormal punishment in a civilized society.

Many Abrahamic and ancient Near-Eastern community faith based traditions differ on this issue. Because capital punishment was in practice during the Old Testament era, there are also many different Christian faith traditions concerning the issue. Many Christians see the New Testament emphasis on ‘grace and forgiveness,’ as being in opposition to the Old Testament law, and a more appropriate response in a civilized society based on Christian principles. They refer to the many occasions in the Gospels when Jesus opposed the ‘inhuman’ laws of the Old Testament, and the ushering in of the Kingdom of God through Jesus mission of action and teaching. Notwithstanding Jesus’ own negative attitude toward those inhuman laws; he himself become a victim of ‘Capital Punishment'.

Meaning and Etymology:

According to the Webster’s New World Dictionary, the word ‘capital' in this context involves punishment by death. The word ‘capital’ comes from the Latin word ‘capitalis,’ that means ‘of the head.’ Decapitation is the be-heading of those who were convicted of crimes deserving the death penalty, for example, murder, treason and other political crimes such as diplomatic-terrorism, rebellion, inciting civil disobedience or any subversive action against government authorities and rulers.





Capital Punishment and Bible:

It is usually the task of rulers, the government or the state to set the legal standards determining the establishment of capital punishment. But even before the establishment of political systems and governments as we know them today, the practice of capital punishment was found in Bible, as if the God of the Old Testament instigates it. For an example, when God made a covenant with Noah, God said...

Whoever sheds the blood of a human, by a human shall that person's blood be shed; for in his own image God made humankind".
Genesis 9:6 (NRSV)

And again in Leviticus in relation to blasphemy and punishment, God said....

"Anyone who kills a human being shall be put to death".
Leviticus 24:17 (NRSV)

Does the God Portrayed in the Bible Institute Capital Punishment?

The Bible portrays God as the God of love and justice, in spite of the above references that appear to indicate an Old Testament God initiated and instituted the death penalty (capital punishment). If the God of the Old Testament is also the God of love and justice, how can we speak about forgiveness and reconciliation in the name of God? In this respect capital punishment becomes not only a social and ethical, but also a theological issue.

God created humans with free will (Genesis 2-3), yet the Ten Commandments given to the multi-national group that came out of Egypt under the leadership of Moses are a basic standard by which the whole human community should live, for their own good and for the good of the whole creation. The Constitution of Great Britain has this biblical basis for its legislation, and the British Legal system is known as the parent of all legal systems in the democratic or ‘free’ world. It is to these Commandments that we look for a revelation of God's ‘position’ in the debate on capital punishment. We can discern the nature of God from these commandments (Exodus 20:13) especially that which says, ‘You shall not murder’ (NRSV). The Hebrew meaning for murder is to ‘slay someone in a violent manner unjustly.’ Therefore God condemned this ‘unjust’ act of taking a life that belongs to God.

The basic philosophy of the Bible is to establish the ‘reign of God’ which is constructed on the values of love, justice, sharing of resources, reciprocal acts of forgiveness and reconciliation, and acceptance of one other. The fundamental reason for the laws (commandments) of God is to establish a ‘crime-free’ society. So the basic vision of the Kingdom of God is such a society where there will not be punishments or crimes.


Jesus and Law: An Over-View:

Jesus, who was portrayed as the Son of God in the Bible, is also a victim of the capital punishment. Does that imply that the Christians worship a 'criminal?' No, the Gospels describe Jesus as a leader who was doing good across all social divides. He was the voice of the voiceless and the defender of the rights of the marginalized. His initiatives inspired a people's movement that was neither anti-authority nor anti-faith. But Jesus was misunderstood and misinterpreted by the state and the religion of the day. A political leader cum judge named `Pontius Pilate' sentenced Jesus to death in order to avert a public riot, but the gospel accounts indicate he clearly acted against his conscience.

Criminal Justice Administration Today:

M .J. Joseph raises several ethical, moral and practical questions relating to the capital punishment. He asks is it possible to change the criminal tendency of an individual? Is the deterrence theory absolutely convincing? Should we not rewrite those aspects of the criminal justice system that are found on vengeance? Is there any relevance for the Christian principles of mercy and forgiveness? Will the poor and the illiterate have access to adequate legal assistance in order to defend themselves?

In many countries, today's legal systems are not very different from those existing in Jesus' time. In every legal system, evidence and witness play a basic and vital role in administering the judgmental proceedings. In every legal system every law has its own loopholes, through which highly creative and articulateive lawyers skillfully help criminals escape punishment. In many cases it is the innocent and the poor who become real victims of these legal systems because it is the wealthy and educated criminals who can engage good lawyers. It is the poor, and all too often the poor innocent, who become victims of harsh punishment, including capital punishment because they cannot afford to pay people to plead for them. Jesus' case is an explicit example; Jesus did not have anyone to speak for him. Neither he nor his disciples employed any such persons. A crowd followed Jesus, shouting Hosanna when he entered into Jerusalem on the day we celebrate now as Palm Sunday, but that crowd were made up of those society discriminated against, the un-touchable, the uneducated and poor, the daily laborers unworthy even to enter the temple premises. So Jesus suffered an unfair trail where only the accuser’s witnesses were considered before passing a sentence of capital punishment. Pontius Pilot was not in a position to stand for truth. Like many judges today, his foremost thought was to safeguard his position of power. The nod of the head goes to the dictating force of the authorities, politicians and leaders of the ruling parties in society.

Too often today, as then, there is no courage to do the right thing. Too often today, as then, there are no human rights protection groups to speak for the innocent. It is our responsibility to remember the victimized innocents by the affluent community, in the name of law and order. But in the name of God we are expected to act as agents of change and act as partners of the establishment of reign of God.
While not supporting the crimes or the criminals, we have to realize that eye-for-an-eye approach to punishment will make the world blind. A civilized world can no longer condone or appreciate retributive justice in legal administration. Rather, we have to accept each other as Jesus did.

A Christian Attitude Towards Capital Punishment:

As a Christians we are supposed to be on the side of reconstructive justice. We have to ask ourselves whether the death penalty is a foolproof method of deterrent? Punishment is not a gospel to proselytize the criminal element of our society. Rather, our vision should be to create a ‘crime-free’ society.

The so-called criminals are psychologically ill persons. We therefore need to have an empathetic and compassionate view towards those involved in serious crimes. Is there any attempt to understand them in this respect, through our current legal systems? It is always possible that the court could find the truly innocent guilty, and thus people are vulnerable to wrongful conviction just as Jesus was. The gospel calls us humans away from a judgmental mindset

An Appeal:

In the light of the above discussion I would like to appeal to every one to have a collective vision, and that vision should not be primarily based on the hanging of the criminals, but on the total transformation of the community in relation to justice, compassion and higher values of like love and acceptance. In the vision of the ‘new heaven and new earth’ there will not be any place for prison and prisoners and even criminals. Hope for the future and the well being of all will be the highest spiritual quest. I would like to conclude this article with the words of Justice K. T. Thomas “ We have one solitary instance in history when a judge found the accused whom he tried as not guilty, but still he sentenced that accused to death penalty to appease a hostile crowd. It happened 2000 years ago in Jerusalem city. The name of the Judge is Pontius Pilothouse and the name of the condemned prisoner was Yeshua the Nazarene.”

References

V. Krishna Iyer, “Marana Thandanikku Marana Thandanai” SOCO Trust, Madurai, 2004. (Tamil).

. . . . . . . . . . . . “Decline of Fair Trail in Asia”, Asian Human Rights Commission, Hong Kong, 2000.
Papers Presented at the ECC during the National Seminar on the Capital Punishment.

Water: A Christian Faith Reflection

Water: A Christian Faith Reflection
Water…
Water is the talk of this era…
Why?
Water is part of our lives, we drink it, wash in it, cook with it, bathe in it,
and it is generally taken it for granted.
This clear, tasteless and odourless liquid is so much part of our lives that we hardly ever think about its amazing properties.
We would even die in a few days without water.
Our bodies contain 75% of water.
Water is necessary to dissolve essential minerals and oxygen,
It flushes out waste products from our bodies and transport nutrients around the body where it is needed.
It is natural and hygienic. We get it from the springs, rivers, and rains and from the earth. Water is the only substance, which has these properties.
But what is the position of water to day? It has taken a prime position in the political agenda of the globe. Even it decides the ruling of the nations'.
Water is the greatest gift of the Creator to all living beings in the Universe.

Water Today:

This 21st Century is marked by the development and progress based on modern Science and Technology. But this neo- development and neo-economical policies do not allow the people to drink Water from the springs. The rivers’ water polluted by the industrial waste, the de-forestation global warming result and the “nil-rain falls” affect the ground water table. The media of this era is forcing us to drink water from the ‘packed bottle’. This reminds us the Jesus’ words in St, Mathew 7: 9-10“… if there any one among you who, if your child asks for bread, will give a stone? Or if the child asks for a fish, will give a snake?” (NRSV). I guess, Jesus would not have thought that the age would come like this. Other wise he would not have uttered these words. Because, if a child asks for food today, the parents are forced to give pizza or lays chips. Or if a child thirsts for water, we give the chemicals like Pepsi and Coke, which are causing danger’. Now rivers are dying, and are sold to the multinational companies. So we as natives of this land are denied of on access to the source of Water. All the faith traditions are considering this element as blessing, sacred, powerful and even as God. Water is not only the political issue but faith issue also. Many can avoid politics and survive but not Water, because it is part of our lives. This paper is an attempt to help us to look the issue of Water from the faith perspective and make us to respond to it.


Water in Different Faiths:

All the polytheistic or pluri-theistic faith traditions considered water as a sacred element. In Hinduism the creator appears after the waters and water appeared after the creator, and they are born from one another (Rig Veda 10.121 Vs 7ff).[1] The same idea is found in II Peter 3: 5-6. “They deliberately ignored the fact, that by the word of God heavens existed long ago and an earth was formed out of water and by means of water...”(NRSV)
And also in ancient-near-east monotheistic faith traditions like ‘Jewish faith tradition’ and ‘Abrahamic faith tradition’, Water is a matter, by which all things are made and Water is the one which purifies and qualifies human to have a proper and cordial relationship with God.[2] And in Abrahamic faith tradition Water is considered as heaven where God Almighty is dwelling. In Genesis 1:2 we read “… the earth was a formless void and darkness covered the face of the deep, while a wind from God swept over the face of the waters”.
The Extra-scriptural faith traditions also consider water as an element, which helps humans to obtain real spiritual purification.

Water in Judeo-Christian Faith Tradition:

As we know the “Middle East” and “Near East” lands are mostly ‘deserts’. It is obvious that there were Water scarcity. So for the people of that land Water is expensive, important, unique and needy. The main source of Water in Palestine is rainfall. This moisture is carried up from the sea in clouds and fall on the hills as rain or snow. This supplies the spring and streams. The Bible was written in that part of the World, where there was no Water.

The rivers in Palestine are mostly small and have little or no Water in summer. Springs mostly supply water to the villages; but in case that is not sufficient, cisterns are used. And limestone is found in many areas; Wells and ponds or pools are not very common. This is why the wells and other water storage systems in the Bible have got names of the diggers. E.g. in Gen 21: 19 Pool of Beersheba, Gen 24:11 Isaac’s Well, John 4:6 Jacob’s Well, John 9:7 Pool of Siloam, Joshua 15:9 The Waters of Nephtoah etc.

Water in the Bible:

As we have seen earlier the scarceness of Water played an important role in the faith journey of the people of the Biblical era. Since water was something that goes with ‘fate’ it was understood by many ways. And it has become the main component as well as symbol in their faith interpretations. Let us see some of them.
Wrath of God:

The prophet Elijah, Jeremiah, and Haggai predict drought as punishment from God (1 Kings 17:1, Jeremiah 14: 1-6 and Haggai 1: 10-11). But conversely the rainfalls are seen and considered as a sign of God’s favor and goodness. The reason for the droughts was seen from the human sin against God. Even today the ‘human’s ecological sin’ bring drought to the world.

Danger and Death:

Water was often associated with danger and death, as in the story of the great flood, the drowning of the Egyptians in the Red Sea and the fear of the Sea and Deep Waters expressed by the Psalmists as in Psalms. 32:6ff. In our context the Dams in the River Cauvery bring death and danger between Tamils and Kannadigas and Dams in Zuttleg brings division between the people of Punjab and Himachal and even People of Tibet.

Polluted Water:

Polluted Water is undrinkable, and it was also a very serious issue when the People of Egypt were affected by plagues, when the water of Nile River turned to blood (Exodus 7: 14-24). And when the Israelites left red sea and came to ‘Mara’, they found the Water of that land was bitter and made a complaint to Moses to perform a miracle. Only upon the collective faith response, the act of God made bitter water into sweet (Exodus 15:22-27). If there will be a collective response towards these issues, the strength will make us free.

War and Water:

In warfare it was a common practice to cut off a city water supply as Josaphat did with the wells of Moab (2 Kings 3: 19-25). The similar events take place even now. And there is an unfortunate prediction that the third world war will be on the sharing and capturing of the water resources.

Water for Cleansing:

In every faith tradition Water is considered as a cleansing element in the ‘spiritual life’. Priests were washed at their consecration (Ex 29:4), special ablutions were demanded for Priests on the Day of Atonement (Lev.16: 4, 24, 6) and of all men for the removal of ceremonial pollution (Lev. 11:40, 15:15, and Deut. 23:11). In Hebrew 10:22, Water is connected with the baptismal cleansing for the forgiveness of sins. Even in our traditions we can see the adherents of another faith go for pilgrimage to the water spots for washing out their sins.

Water is Spiritual Refreshment:

Water is also a symbolic of God’s blessing and spiritual refreshment. This can be noted in many places in the Bible. E.g. (Isaiah’s vision of the return to the redeemed to Zion) Isaiah 35:6-7 “… For Waters shall break forth in the wilderness, and streams in the desert; the burning sand shall become a pool, and the thirsty ground springs of water...”And another reference from Isaiah 41: 17-18 “When the poor and needy seek water and there is none, and their toung is parched with thirst, I the Lord will answer them, I the God of Israel will not forsake them. I will open rivers on the bare heights and fountains in the midst of valleys; I will make the wilderness a pool of water, and the dry land springs of water”.

Water is Spiritual Need:

Psalmist says in Psalms. 42:1. “As a deer longs for flowing of streams, my soul long for you, O God” This is a unique faith expression of the people in Bible. Because water only satisfies our thirsty need no other material. No human in the world would say ‘enough’ for any of their wants except ‘Water’.

Water and Women:

Even today the Women and girls are walking a long distance and spend hours together ever-single day to provide the household with water. Not only now even during the biblical ages also women had similar experiences. The experience of the Samaritan woman in John’s Gospel (4: 1-15) and Rebecca in Genesis 24: 15-21 are dealing with water and life. So it is so obvious that women play a vital role in the utilization, provision, management and save of water in the Society. Along with the other oppressions the water problem also oppresses women today. But women are the best water managers, each and every women of today are very well in how to utilize and manage the available water. The women are very practical teachers to the family in teaching hoe to manage water. Especially the forth-coming generations Children are to be educated and encouraged in water management and to use the water in a very responsible manner.

Water is Right:

Water issue is the basic human right issue, because water is essential for life. We see poor and village women are running after the water tankers even in the midnights. Some times they force the government to provide, at least minimum water supply, by the strikes and disturbing the traffic, marching to the local authorities and they mostly achieve these demands to an extent from the governments and local authorities. The biblical characters like Hagar in Genesis 21: 14-21 is a classical example of fighting with God for water. Who made the Biblical God to provide water in the dessert! And in Exodus 15:22-27 the Israelites made God of the Bible to purify the undrinkable water into drinkable water. These incidents show the responsibilities of the God of the Bible in fulfilling the thirst of the people, because Water is the basic and fundamental right of each and every individual human being to have enough water for their thirst.

Water is Life:

In John’s Gospel Jesus is portrayed as ‘life’. The same Jesus in the same Gospel says that He is the living Water, because Water is life. This concept can only be understood by the people who live in the context of scarce of Water. Prophet Jeremiah describes God as “the fountain of living Waters (Jeremiah. 2: 13 and 17:13)”. And in John 4:14 Jesus says that “… but those who drink of the water that I give them will never be thirsty. The water that I will give will become in them a spring of water gushing up to eternal life”. According to John the living water is water for life, which liberates the people from their bondage. This life giving water will satisfy the thirst of the needy. And God-self is the only component who satisfies the thirsty one. So it is very easy for us to understand that God-self is water.[3] We all believe that we are all created in the image of God (Gen.1: 27ff). The image of God should not be understood by the physical image but by the attributes of God. If so when we see God as Water, which gives life to the Society, so we will have to reflect that Image also.

Faith Application for Action:

We can live without politics but not Water. The ancient Greek Philosopher says “one could never put one’s own feet in the same river water twice.” This saying talks about the ever-changing natural character of Water. Waters are forever moving, cascading down mountains, flowing over the plains at a snail’s pace, the levels rising and falling with the seasons, on their journey to the sea. . This life giving characters are to be reflected in faith journey. ‘Water is Life’ and ‘God is Water’ are supposed to be considered as Gospel rather, which are to be made known to the Society. And also the church or any other faith community is to be made spiritually sensitive to this issue. We just cannot use water as we want, because Water, which we use, is not our ancestral property. It is Biblically a 'gift' of the 'Creator' for all living beings.

“Water is our blood and marrow
Water is not a commodity
Water is gift of the Creator to all living beings
To be shared, to be valued
And
To be protected
For our corporate survival
Let us celebrate life with water.” [4]

Bibliography
Batten, Don, “Red-blooded Evidence”, Creation, SRS, London, 1997.
Faruqui, Naser, (Ed.s), “Water Management in Islam”, International Development Research Centre, UN University Press. 1999.
Radice, Betty, (Adv.Ed,), "The Rig Veda", Penguin Classics, London, 1981.

Other Sources
M.J. Joseph, “Poem on Water”, Displayed at ECC Whitefield, Bangalore.
Mays, James L., (Gen.Ed), “Harper’s Bible Commentary”, Harper, San Francisco, New York, 1988.
Encyclopedia Britannica (15th Edition.) 1992.
New Bible Dictionary, (3rd Edition), Inter-Versity Press, Leicester, 1996.
, 4 -6Sept. 2004.

[1] Betty, Radice (Adv.Ed,), The Rig Veda, Penguin Classics, London, 1981. P.26.
[2] Naser, Faruqui (EDs), Water Management In Islam, P.15ff.

[3] James L. Mays, (Gen.Ed), Harper’s Bible Commentary, Harper, San Francisco, New York, 1988. p.1052.
[4] M.J. Joseph “Poem on Water”, Displayed at ECC Whitefield, Bangalore.